June 28, 2014
"We must make clear agreements!"
What I sometimes see is that when people within an organization focus strongly on establishing clear agreements and rules they do not achieve what they ultimately want to achieve. It often seems as if the agreements and rules have become the goal instead of what lies behind the agreements and rules which is what they originally wanted to achieve through the agreements and rules. The risk of a strong (strict) focus on agreements and rules is that you make the motivation of employees more extrinsic and controlled. This may lead to the situation in which people will only do what is minimally required or in which they will even cheat in order to only seemingly comply with the rules.
An alternative approach is to not focus primarily on rules and agreements (these are at best means to an end) but on the desired situation. What are we trying to accomplish, why is that important and what different ways can we think of to make progress in that direction? What progress have we already made in that direction? What were some past successes? What has worked well? What useful ideas come to mind when we think about these things? What I often find is that such a way of working can yield some more creative ideas that are more motivating and useful than making a list of agreements and rules.