December 10, 2012

A not so well-known downside of advice giving

I think the effectiveness of giving advice is, in general, overrated. Even when advice sounds reasonable and useful, people may still be reluctant to act upon it. In this post I argue that solutions which are self-found and based on one's own previous experience have a better change of being accepted and used.

Now I came across evidence which suggests that advice may also be not so beneficial for the person giving it: Advising someone to act in a certain way may make it less likely that you yourself will act in that way.

Quite surprising. But it does provide an explanation for a the situation of a doctor I once knew well was in. He seemed to do everything doctors are supposed to advice their patients to stay away from (heavy smoking, eating, drinking, not exercising, etc.). 

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner